Speculations in Sin

Starred review from January 15, 2024
Her latest brush with Victorian intrigue takes Kat Holloway far from her comfort zone. That zone is pretty capacious because Kat's already had extensive experience with mysteries. So when Mr. Davis, the butler at the Mayfair home of the Bywater family, where Kat serves as a cook, goes off without notice one day and still hasn't returned by bedtime, fans will nod knowingly. But they'll be wrong, because Davis turns up the next day angry that Kat's been going through his things looking for clues to his whereabouts and unwilling to supply any details about his unplanned day off. The murder, when it comes, strikes in quite a different venue: the third-floor strong room of Daalman's Bank, where Samuel Millburn, the husband of Kat's dear friend Joanna Millburn, toiled as a clerk until he was suspected of embezzlement and fired. Hours later, the body of Stockley, a senior clerk who doesn't merit a first name, is found beaten to death. Roderick Kearny, a Daalman's banker who'd befriended Sam, is solicitous, but head banker Harmon Zachary and Miss Swann, the Daalman relative who clearly directs Zachary's every move, are anything but. Although Judith Townsend, an artist friend of the Bywaters' niece Lady Cynthia, engages a solicitor and a barrister for Sam, the work of finding exculpatory evidence falls to Kat. Menaced by Ben Jarrett, an old mate of Sam's from his early years as a street tough, and well aware that she's entering a man's world, Kat calls once more on Daniel McAdam, a freelancer who runs hush-hush errands for Scotland Yard, for help, and together they push the case toward an eminently predictable solution. A generally routine period piece most notable for the sleuth's unexpectedly chilling climactic confrontation with the killer.

COPYRIGHT(2024) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.